Ezra Miller crosses the road as Trashcan Man in The Stand episode 6

Ezra Miller crosses the line as Trashcan Man in The Stand episode 6

“The Vigil,” the sixth episode of CBS All Access’ The Stand, introduces Donald Elbert, who turns into a key participant in Randall Flagg’s plot in opposition to the world. Donald is thought to followers of Stephen King’s apocalyptic opus by his extra catchy nickname: Trashcan Man.

Trash has every thing Randall Flagg, the Big Bad of the story, is on the lookout for in a servant. He’s loyal, he’s damaging, and he’s actually good at discovering what stays of the US Army’s arsenal scattered across the Mojave Desert. As King illustrates within the textual content, he additionally offers with persistent psychological sickness stemming from a lifetime of ache and trauma. That’s the place issues get slightly tough for writer-director Josh Boone and showrunner Benjamin Cavell in relation to adapting the character for display.

[Ed. observe: This story accommodates minor spoilers for “The Vigil” and former episodes of The Stand.]

Ezra Miller (Justice League, Fantastic Beasts) had a hell of a job in entrance of him when agreed to play Trashcan Man. In the novel, King dedicates pages and pages to the character’s complicated backstory, detouring the plot by means of a scenic route of his psychological state. Readers be taught that, as an eight-year-old, he began lighting his neighbor’s trash cans on hearth (therefore the nickname). Later, the elder Elbert killed Donald’s siblings and practically completed off the entire household earlier than the native cops intervened. The cop who shot his deranged father turned the troubled boy’s stepfather, and the data impacted him at a core degree. King devotes a number of pages to Donald’s time at a psychological hospital as a younger teenager, the place he was compelled to endure shock remedy, the other of the assistance he wanted.

A restricted collection doesn’t have the identical actual property as a 1,000-page ebook, so there have been at all times going to be just a few shortcuts when it got here to an adaptation. But when coping with a personality with psychological well being points, the mistaken shortcut can cross over the razor-thin line between considerate illustration and caricature.

To that finish, Miller takes an enormous swing with the 2020 model of Trashcan Man — however he whiffed it. Having watched the episode twice now, I can say the efficiency has to shoulder the vast majority of blame. What sends the character into over-the-line territory isn’t how he’s written, it’s all in Miller’s line supply and physicality.

Ezra Miller in The Stand episode 6 speaking to Randall Flag by a hotel room fire

Randall Flagg (Alexander Skarsgård) speaks to Trashcan Man (Miller) on The Stand
Image: CBS All Access

On the floor, that is the Trashcan Man from the ebook. We meet him within the technique of blowing up oil tankers (similar to within the ebook); we see him being being drawn to Randall Flagg, who is aware of {that a} promise of fireplace is all it’ll take to win this poor, tragic character’s loyalty (similar to within the ebook); and we see him introduced earlier than Flagg himself in Vegas the place The Walking Dude units him on a mission to search out the weapons that might obliterate the goodie two-shoes over in Boulder for good (similar to within the ebook).

Donald is an excessive character that calls for an excessive efficiency, however the decisions Miller makes border on offensive psychological sickness stereotypes. His screeching line supply of Trashcan Man’s most iconic phrase “My life for you!” sounds extra like bullying imitation relatively than an sincere portrayal of somebody with psychiatric disabilities. That extends to his bodily efficiency as nicely. In dialog with Flagg, he repeatedly and exaggeratedly slams his burned arm to his chest in a method that recollects former President Trump’s mockery of a reporter’s bodily incapacity in 2015. At the time, that echoed the worst form of schoolyard taunts, and so does Miller’s efficiency.

Tom Cullen is one other of The Stand’s characters who may simply tumble into offensiveness, however turns into nuanced within the arms of actor Brad William Henke. King waffles slightly bit within the ebook on what sort of incapacity Tom has: Sometimes it’s described as a slight mental developmental dysfunction (“Light mental retardation,” as Lloyd places it in now-defunct language), generally he’s simply gradual, King suggesting midway by means of the ebook that “most folks took Tom’s sudden blackouts as a further sign of retardation, but they were actually instances of nearly normal thinking.” Over the years, Tom Cullen has turn into considered one of King’s most beloved characters because of his big coronary heart and selfless nature.

Henke, greatest identified for appearances in Split and Orange Is the New Black, nails Tom’s purity and acknowledges his dysfunction in a method that feels grounded. His distinctive thoughts is barely a part of his id as a personality, not essentially his defining trait. On paper, Henke confronted the identical primary challenges as Miller, however strikes a steadiness that doesn’t veer off into absurdity. Tom has memorized a regular greeting that he repeats over and over, informing whoever he’s speaking to about his developmental incapacity. The present’s writers use this repetition to carry some humor to the character with out making enjoyable of him. Henke himself provides a lot what-you-see-is-what-you-get honesty to his efficiency, and it’s turn into a spotlight relatively than a ache level of this new incarnation of The Stand.

Tom Cullen (Brad Henke) on The Stand wearing a butcher’s apron and hairnet, covered in blood

Tom Cullen (Brad Henke) on The Stand
Photo: Robert Falconoer/CBS

Mother Abigail is one other tough character to drag off within the modern-day. Thanks to the non-linear method to this adaptation, a lot of the 108-year-old character’s impression on the story is sidelined. When the collection opens, we’re already in Boulder with the great guys, attempting to jumpstart the brand new civilization. The linear model would have all the primary characters dreaming of this mysterious outdated girl, calling them to her one after the other because the survivors of the tremendous flu select their sides. With much less time to flesh out Mother Abigail, Whoopi Goldberg’s job to make an impression and produce dimension turns into tougher.

Goldberg spoke brazenly throughout a New York Comic Con digital panel about how she did every thing she may to keep away from the “magical negro” criticism that has dogged the character since publication, and he or she largely succeeds even with a extra restricted display presence. Much like Trashcan Man, Mother Abigail advantages tremendously within the novel from King giving us a tour by means of her thought course of, illuminating the important thing occasions in her very lengthy life that put her within the place to be the figurehead for all the great guys on this story. Even in a nine-hour restricted collection there isn’t a lot time to dive into all of Mother Abigail’s insecurity, dedication, delight, knowledge, and ache gained from outliving everybody she’s ever beloved, however Goldberg, a longtime fan of the character who even tried to beat out Ruby Dee for the function again in 1994, infuses the character with a quiet energy, and thru sheer pressure of her expositional dialogue hints on the complicated backstory that we by no means get to see.

Henke made essentially the most of his time as Tom Cullen, Goldberg has made essentially the most of her time as Mother Abigail, however Miller has began off his interpretation on a foot so mistaken I’m anticipating social media to be flooded with a sure GIF of Robert Downey Jr. in Tropic Thunder. It’s attainable the primary impression will not be indicative of a layered efficiency down the road; there are three extra episodes left earlier than The Stand’s finale, and Trashcan Man performs an vital function within the ending of the story. He will come to see that whereas he worships and adores Randall Flagg, the opposite individuals in Flagg’s camp are the identical sorts of bullies who set him down the trail of madness to start with.

Trash shall be torn between his devotion to the chief and his hatred of everyone else, which is loads of meat for an actor. There could also be some steadiness dropped at the efficiency by the top, however “The Vigil” is the form of bad-taste introduction that may be inconceivable to get well from. The Stand, finally, is stuffed with these sorts of highs and lows. I’ll by no means be fully bought on the fractured narrative method to this story, which I really feel undercuts the “feeling” of the ebook, which positioned you in a world because it was falling aside, made you reside in it as in the event you had been there, after which introduced you alongside on the great guys’’ journey to rebuild. As a longtime fan of the ebook, it’s good to see so many nice actors handing over positive work as a few of my favourite literary characters. But if Henke and Goldberg characterize the present’s highs, then Miller represents the present’s lowest low, and a lesson for all future actors who search to carry such a complexity to life.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.