The final narrative movie distributed by Netflix that was primarily based on actual occasions, The Red Sea Diving Resort, was a multitude of clichés with a foul case of white-savior complicated. Sergio, the streaming big’s newest stab at tackling historical past, fares a bit of higher. Greg Barker, a filmmaker identified for his documentaries Ghosts of Rwanda and Manhunt: The Search for Bin Laden, turns his eye to function storytelling with a biographical drama about United Nations diplomat Sérgio Vieira de Mello, primarily based on Barker’s documentary of the identical title. Vieira de Mello was a storied diplomat, aiding in hostage conditions, serving to usher previously occupied nations to independence, and coordinating humanitarian operations by means of his profession, and Barker’s apparent care and respect for his topic makes Sergio stirring to observe. But as Craig Borten’s script leans increasingly on romance, the movie flounders.
Borten’s massive gimmick is intelligent: he has the majority of the movie play out in a collection of flashbacks as Sergio (Wagner Moura) is stranded within the particles of the 2003 Canal Hotel bombing in Iraq. Free from having to inform Sergio’s story chronologically, Borten and Barker as an alternative skip round by means of occasions, establishing the diplomat’s bona fides when it comes to his real care and talent at championing these not in energy (focusing particularly on his guiding East Timor to independence), then filling within the particulars of his private life and his stationing in Iraq.
Ana de Armas stars as economist Carolina Larriera, who grew to become concerned with Sergio (although he was nonetheless married on the time) whereas they had been working in East Timor. The film makes use of the evolution of their bond and Sergio’s willingness to decide to a relationship (any relationship, as he tells her early on that he’s “not too good with indefinite assignments”) as a mirror for a way critically he took the work he was doing, and the individuals he was serving to. The setup there feels a bit of shallow, particularly as Sergio and Carolina’s romance takes up increasingly time, stealing dramatic heft from Sergio’s humanitarian efforts.
Carolina’s presence helps set up Sergio’s human facet as she opens a door into his private life. But that function might simply as simply have gone to Sergio’s right-hand man Gil (a composite character performed by Brían F. O’Byrne), who finally ends up trapped within the rubble with him. Their friendship spans years and nations, and is telling about each Sergio’s work and Sergio as an individual. The push and pull between Gil and Sergio is arguably the identical dynamic Sergio encounters in coping with the U.S. authorities in Iraq. During their time in East Timor, Gil doesn’t at all times see the individuals they cope with as equals. He appears to be like down on the non-college-educated rebels, however Sergio makes him see in another way by means of how he offers with the state of affairs on a human stage. In Iraq, Sergio has to cope with one thing comparable, as he has to persuade L. Paul Bremer III (Bradley Whitford) that reopening Abu Ghraib isn’t the reply to ending resistance in Iraq.
But these particulars get misplaced within the dreamy sequences portraying Carolina and Sergio’s romance, starting from likelihood conferences whereas jogging to walks within the rain to grand romantic gestures, full with paper hearts and string lights. These sequences don’t have a lot to say about Sergio, whereas the detour into his private life that doesn’t contain her — he has dinner along with his sons, and, absent as he’s, forgets their meals allergy symptoms — says volumes extra about him and his imperfections.
Though the romance is full of clichés, the dramatization of Sergio’s work feels very important. The key to his success is his humanity — he insists that the individuals he meets merely name him by his first title, and he talks to everybody, from troopers on the road to political leaders, one-to-one. He additionally understands why individuals would possibly resist the U.N.’s efforts, particularly as they cooperate with the U.S. authorities. And his work attempting to repair components of American historical past which can be usually glossed over is fascinating.
Amazon’s The Report is much less a biopic and extra a dramatization of historic occasions, but it surely nonetheless focuses on a single character within the midst of political turmoil — Daniel Jones, performed by Adam Driver, who led an investigation of the CIA’s Detention and Interrogation Program. Where that film succeeds is in specializing in presenting the info of what was occurring within the aftermath of 9/11, and in telling the reality. Sergio excels when it’s doing the identical factor, however its larger story about Sergio’s humanitarian efforts succumbs to its love story. What ought to be a narrative about one man’s extraordinary love of humanity turns right into a story about his abnormal love of 1 lady.
Sergio is streaming on Netflix now.
Vox Media has affiliate partnerships. These don’t affect editorial content material, although Vox Media might earn commissions for merchandise bought through affiliate hyperlinks. For extra data, see our ethics coverage.