Any father or mother can let you know that elevating a baby is a daunting prospect. It’s no shock, then, that the queasy sublimated worry of a rising, puking, shrieking alien Thing in the home has fueled many a traditional horror movie, from Rosemary’s Baby (about being pregnant) to The Exorcist (about pre-pubescent children performing out) to Carrie (about youngsters performing out). Kids: at any age, they gasoline nightmares about lack of management and comprehension.
The Shudder horror film The Room, newly launched on DVD by RLJE Films, places a brand new twist on the style of offspring-horror by addressing a number of child-development levels directly, to create an unsightly, puling, acne-scarred smorgasbord of parental nightmares. The breadth of the endeavor is sudden, and it lets debut director Christian Volckman information his movie by way of a lot of intelligent twists. Unfortunately, the dearth of focus additionally results in an absence of depth. The Room does get at a number of the mundane tedium of child-rearing. But that doesn’t precisely make for an incredible horror movie.
[Ed. word: Mild spoilers for The Room under.]
The Room begins as a younger enticing skilled couple, Kate (Olga Kurylenko) and Matt (Kevin Janssens) transfer to a distant Maryland city to rehab a home. In the course of their renovations, they open a mysterious locked room which can magically grant them something they need. All they must do is ask. Then the home lights flicker, and no matter they want is sitting there: bourbon, Van Gogh work, cash, and extra.
What the 2 actually need, although, is a baby. Kate has had a number of miscarriages. When she asks the room for a child, it offers her a boy they title Shane. After some uncertainty and argument, they resolve to maintain him. As anybody who’s learn W.W. Jacobs’ 1902 story “The Monkey’s Paw” might have predicted, issues go steadily, albeit inventively, improper from there.
The strongest side of The Room is the best way it reveals Kate and Matt’s relationship altering after Shane comes into their lives. Every father or mother with a accomplice worries how the introduction of a small third wheel will have an effect on love, intercourse, and family chores. The Room is stable at sketching a sequence of convincing worst-case prospects.
At the start of the film, Kate is an achieved translator who strides about the home in overalls, competently contributing to dwelling renovations. When Shane reveals up, although, she’s shortly and helplessly maneuvered into claustrophobic, overprotective domesticity. Her pursuits contract to Shane, who resents her hovering and the seemingly arbitrary limitations she units on him.
Matt, in the meantime, descends into paranoid, Oedipally tinged jealousy of the bond between his spouse and not-son, the latter of whom he needs to each shield and destroy. Tensions solely worsen when the household cash begins to actually go up in smoke, even earlier than the central couple begins fascinated about a school fund. The baby infests and warps the household unit, hoovering up sources, and alienating Kate and Matt from one another.
That setup is stable, however the execution is much less so. In actually efficient offspring horror like The Witch or Hereditary or The Shining, the filmmakers fastidiously construct up the dysfunctional household dynamics earlier than the supernatural weirdness begins, so the escalating darkness has a queasy karmic resonance.
But The Room — with an hour and 40 minutes during which to cowl infancy to adolescence — skimps on the setup. Is Matt a sexist abuser, like Jack in The Shining, or only a good man caught in a foul state of affairs? The construction of the movie means that Kate ought to be torn between her profession and child-rearing, just like the mother in The Exorcist. But she doesn’t appear to care a lot about her translation job, and she or he’s granted no different non-familial ambitions. Kurylenko and Janssens are completely competent actors, however neither has the gravitas to create a memorable character within the enamel of the incoherent script. As a consequence, the darkness within the movie appears to happen off to the aspect of Matt and Kate’s private foibles, fairly than rising from them like some malevolent, fanged baby.
Shane’s improvement additionally suffers from the film’s unsure pacing and unwillingness to commit. Demonic kids are a stable horror staple, however The Room is oddly tentative in imagining Shane’s uncanniness. He doesn’t urinate in the lounge whereas intoning, “You’re going to die up there,” like Regan within the Exorcist; his eyes don’t have the unearthly glow of the youngsters in Children of the Damned; his smile isn’t haunting like Damien’s in The Omen.
Instead, the perfect Shane can muster is a peevish crankiness. He refuses to concentrate whereas Kate teaches him to learn. He throws eggs on the wall. Yes, he looks as if a reasonably exasperating, high-maintenance child, however not a psychotic or unnatural one. When he begins doing actually horrible issues towards the film’s finish, his actions appear unmotivated, and never totally justified by what’s gone earlier than. Again, the build-up and foreshadowing — usually the perfect a part of horror movies — falls flat.
The weak pacing and characterization imply The Room is much less enjoyable to observe than it might be. But what actually leaves a bland aftertaste is its detached dealing with of its personal deeper considerations.
At first The Room toys with a critique of middle-class capitalist greed and consumption. “I know your kind. Creatures of need. You crave and you crave and you crave and then you die,” one foreboding expositor tells Mark. But the reality is that neither Mark nor Kate appear that materialistic. They don’t have determined cash troubles. Kate can barely determine what to ask for after they first determine how the room works, and when she lastly needs for cash, Mark is dumbfounded, and asks, “Why didn’t I think of that?” Rarely has the “be careful what you wish for” trope been deployed on a pair with much less curiosity in wishing.
After Volckman figures out that he doesn’t actually care that a lot about capitalism, he begins to circle round matters like reproductive selection. Matt pressures Kate about reproductive choices in very uncomfortable methods. At the identical time, abortion and standard adoption look like choices the couple ought to actively think about at varied factors within the narrative, however neither is ever talked about. Rather than utilizing modern debates and contexts round child-rearing to complement the film, Volckman carves out a magic chamber the place parental choices are artificially restricted. As a consequence, the plot at many factors feels contrived, and the themes confused.
The Room isn’t horrible, and it isn’t unwatchable. On the opposite, horror followers will discover it a wholly competent, sometimes ingenious style train with an uncommon surfeit of concepts. And it’s exactly that surfeit of concepts which makes the execution disappointing. The Room isn’t precisely a failure. But the delights it guarantees are a lot much less satisfying and far more ephemeral than those it appears to supply. Instead of extravagant achievement, all that poofs into existence are some acquainted and shortly dissipating pleasures. Viewers can solely hope that Volckman births some much less disappointing inventive progeny within the close to future.
The Room is streaming on Shudder and is accessible for digital rental on Amazon, Vudu, and different providers.
Vox Media has affiliate partnerships. These don’t affect editorial content material, although Vox Media might earn commissions for merchandise bought through affiliate hyperlinks. For extra info, see our ethics coverage.